Mike Lucas' Upon Further Review: Every team has plenty of 'what-ifs'
Mike Lucas
11/24/2008
The Capital Times
SPORTS
Text Size: A A A
Page 1 of 3
Email this article Email
Print this article Print

What if Cal Poly placekicker Andrew Gardner hadn't missed three extra points in 36-35 loss to the Wisconsin Badgers football team? What if Fresno State placekicker Kevin Gossling hadn't missed three field goals in a 13-10 loss to the Badgers?

But wait.

What if Wisconsin placekicker Philip Welch hadn't missed a 34-yard field goal in a 27-25 loss at Michigan? Or what if Welch hadn't missed a 44-yard field goal in a 25-24 loss at Michigan State?

But wait.

What if Ohio State's Brian Robiskie wasn't hustling downfield and wasn't in a position to recover Brian Hartline's fumble on the Buckeyes' game-winning scoring drive against the Badgers?

And what if Minnesota doesn't self-destruct in the second half after carrying the fight to the Badgers for the first 30 minutes while taking a 21-7 lead?

But wait.

What if the UW coaching staff had decided last spring or last summer or this fall that Dustin Sherer gave this team a better chance to win than Allan Evridge?

What if Kirk DeCremer was available to spell the starting defensive ends, Matt Shaughnessy and O'Brien Schofield? Or, what if cornerback Aaron Henry was around to shore up the secondary?

What if Travis Beckum had stayed healthy during his senior year? Or, what if Beckum hadn't lined up wrong on a two-point conversion at Michigan? Would the Badgers have won in overtime?

(Don't be surprised, either, if Beckum doesn't have the same impact in the NFL as former Purdue tight end, Dustin Keller, who has become one of Brett Favre's favorite receivers with the New York Jets. The 6-foot-2, 248-pound Keller had 142 catches for 1,882 career yards and 16 touchdowns at Purdue. The 6-4, 235-pound Beckum had 159 catches for 2,149 career yards and 11 touchdowns here before going on the shelf with an injury.)

But wait.

What if UW coach Bret Bielema hadn't lost his temper with the officiating at Michigan State? What if Bielema had kept his poise on the sidelines throughout the game -- would that crew still have flagged Badgers center John Moffitt for holding?

What if the UW defense was aligned properly before Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Pryor took the snap and scored the game-winning touchdown with little or no resistance from the linebackers?

But wait. You can play the "what if'' game to distraction or insanity.

Whichever comes first.

And it's no different here than it is for 118 other Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) teams and at least one Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) team, Cal Poly.

But don't shed a tear for the Mustangs, who have landed a home game for the first round of the playoffs. Cal Poly will draw Weber State (coached by Ron McBride, the former Utah head coach and Badgers offensive line assistant under Dave McClain).

What a concept.

A 16-team playoff.

Are the FCS student-athletes that superior academically to the FBS student-athletes in that they can afford to miss all of that precious class time because of the existence of a playoff, whereas we continue to hear that missed classtime excuse at the FBS level? It's all BS. You're right.

If Cal Poly gets past Weber State, the Mustangs will get a rematch with Montana, which escaped with an early season 30-28 win when Andrew Gardner missed a 27-yard field goal in the final seconds.

■ ■ Next
Text Size: A A A
Page 1 of 3
Email this article Email
Print this article Print
9 comment posts
Last Reply: 12/1/2008 5:18 PM
Mike Lucas' Upon Further Review: Every team has plenty of 'what-ifs'
(12/1/2008 5:18 PM)
BigTenFan says:
Lucas, you are such a homer!! Sure, the badgers qualified for a bowl game. Did their performance this season justify one??? Nope!

Minnesota 3-5 overall 7-5 bucky 3-5 overall 7-5.

Records look the same to me...

Oh, and the MSU game holding call? If the same call had been made against MSU, you whining badger fans would have claimed it was a "great call!!" Quit whining!! You make us look worse than we already do!!

Go Bucky!
(11/25/2008 8:35 AM)
Vic says:
Well, put, CalPolyAlum.

Thanks to the Badgers the chance to measure ourselves against a BCS caliber team.
(11/24/2008 6:21 PM)
CalPolyAlum says:
Just wanted to thank Wisconsin for scheduling this game. While we may knock off some mid-majors from time to time, this was a once in a generation opportunity to play a top-tier BCS school, with the best team we've had since a 1980 D-2 National Championship team. Understand we had our whole offense returning with possibly the two best 1-AA players (QB & Receiver) at those positions, so don't dismiss the struggles your defense had as a mediocre performance. In spite of all that's been said, you WON the game with a comeback and did what you had to win, completing a 2-pt conversion when you had to.
(11/24/2008 2:39 PM)
GoBadgers says:
What a bunch of whiny babies! Get a grip! If you burn your tickets at 7-5, what is an acceptable non-ticket burning season record......8-4? I haven't done any research, but I don't think Don Morton's record was close to 28-10 after his first 3 seasons.
(11/24/2008 2:25 PM)
BADGERBOY says:
Are division 2 kids smarter thab division 1 kids. Any moron can play at division 1 level if the school cuts corners to get them enrolled. When you have guys with a 7th grade IQ getting enrolled figure it out for yourself. Can someone pleas explain the UW coaches failure to adjust to Cal-Poly running those QB sneaks time after time. Even Peewee league coaches would have made adjustments.
(11/24/2008 11:54 AM)
dave says:
Go ahead and burn your tickets, I would hate to see what you would do if you were a Minnesota fan Started the season as a 7-1 team and end up with a 55-0 loss. Thank God our team isn't that bad
(11/24/2008 11:22 AM)
Brian says:
MVP? My candidates are: (1) Philip Welch, who could actually make an extra point v. Cal Poly; or (2) the goal post in the North end zone at Camp Randall, which the Cal Poly kicker had a problem with. Actually the MVPs by default are PJ Hill and Mike Newkirk. Thanks to some of the worst coaching at UW since Don Morton was prowling the sidelines, essentially no one on offense or defense played up to their potential. This team will be remembered for mental errors, lack of toughness, penalties, turnovers, second-half meltdowns, failure to have 11 men on the field, coaching blunders, being outcoached by a FCS-level coach who did not even have a headset as well as Coach Rodriguez of UM. Thanks to Coach B for a thrilling season of Badger football.


(11/24/2008 8:45 AM)
Badger Fan says:
What if, Coach Bielema hadn't HAD to call a timeout at the end of the Michigan State game to get his whole special team out their for MSU's rushed field goal attempt? Oh wait...Silly me, I forgot Coach B said that timeout was to "ice" the kicker!
(11/24/2008 8:31 AM)
Barry says:
What if, I get another letter in the mail from the Badger Fund telling me to contribute because we have to pay more money to keep great coaches to keep our program amongst the best. I might burn the rest of my tickets. Thank gosh this season is over. No bowl for me as my team didn't deserve one.
This email is never shared.
Badgerbeat.com monitors COMMENTS posted online. We reserve the right to edit or delete any message or shut down a disucssion at any time if, in our judgement, comments become offensive, threatening or libelous. Poster Terms and Conditions
BadgerBeat.com Copyright 2008 Capital Newspapers, Inc.